Gary N. Johnson Insurance Agency

Location Address:

519 Washington St.

Jamestown, NY 14701


Monday – Friday

8:00am – 4:00pm


Mailing Address:

P.O. Box 3026

Jamestown, NY 14702

Member of

Professional Insurance Agents


Insurance Agents



Phone: 716-483-5525

Fax: 716-664-0933

Companies we represent

Our Team

Robin Kiendl

Licensed Agent

Kayley Guy

Administrative Assistant

Request an insurance quote

Serving Chautauqua County and the surrounding areas, we are licensed in New York and Pennsylvania. Simply click here, call, email or stop in and see us for all of your personal and commercial insurance needs.

Gary N. Johnson Insurance Agency Sign

Gary started in the insurance industry in 1969. In 1983 he established Gary N. Johnson Insurance Agency. Today, Robin Johnson, the second generation, is operating the agency. We represent several regional and national companies and offer multiple lines of personal and commercial insurance to meet your needs. We offer personalized and professional service to our customers and strive to stay competitive in today's insurance industry. Call us for a free quote today and let us show you how we stand apart from online and 1-800 companies. We can be your one stop shop for safety and security.


Stephen & Jennifer Eckwahl

"I am so pleased with the service that I received from the Gary N. Johnson Insurance Agency. I dealt specifically with Robin who was absolutely terrific in assisting me with my needs. My husband and I had our house listed on the market to sell, and because the house was vacant, we had to switch our homeowners insurance to a different company. Not only did Robin bring this issue to my attention before the insurance company did, but she went out of her way to find us the cheapest quote possible and emailed us the application in no time at all for the new policy! I would recommend the Gary N. Johnson Agency to anyone who is looking for an insurance agency who places customer service as their top priority and goes above and beyond to make sure that you are completely satisfied with your experience!"

Chautauqua Lake Snowmobile Services LLC, NY

"This note is to compliment Gary N. Johnson Insurance Agency for their excellent service and coverage. We are very pleased with their dependability and expertise!"

Tim Johnson

"In this day of digital/electronic communication, we have all lost one on the most important features in life - personal contact, communication and service. Although, I agree that change and improvement is necessary, the Gary N. Johnson Insurance Agency has not lost sight of the importance of personal service. They have always had a trained person at the end of the phone line or in the office willing you service any of your needs. They take every concern/question and problem as if it was their own. I have been with this agency for 40 years. My family has always done business there and I have referred a number of people to them. I must emphasize the word "family" because that's what I feel when dealing with this agency. It is a family run business that treats you like family. You buy insurance in hopes that you never will need/use it. You can be assured that when the day occurs that you suffer a loss or damage, they will be there as your agent to assist you in any way possible. Most agencies will tell you to contact their adjustor upon a loss, not so with this agency. They will walk with you through the process and make sure it is handled properly. That in itself is a comfort to know. They will evolve with you as your insurance needs change and understand the day to day costs that each of us face. They earn your premiums every day and are always concerned about reducing your costs yet not compromising your benefits. What more could anyone ask?"

Bill & Laurie Scully

"I was referred to this insurance agency from a friend. Their rates were very competitive but what really sold me on changing to their agency was the friendly, professional, prompt customer service. I have been with several insurance agencies over the years (changed mostly from increasing high premiums and poor customer service), now I have exceptional service and great rates. Any questions regarding my policies are quickly researched and handled in a very pleasant manner. I would highly recommend making the change, I'm glad I did."