Skip to main content
Close Search
Gary N. Johnson Insurance Agency
search
Menu
  • Insurance Solutions
    • –
      • Personal Insurance
        • Auto
        • Home
        • Secondary Home
        • See All
      • Insurance by Industry
        • Landlord and Rental Property
        • Property Manager
        • Retail Business
        • See All
    • –
      • Business Insurance
        • Business Auto
        • Commercial Property
        • General Liability
        • See All
    • Explore Interactive GraphicsClick it. Read it. Cover it.
  • About
    • About Our Agency
      • Meet the Owner
      • Read Our Reviews
      • Insurance Companies
      • We Are Independent
      • Renaissance Alliance
    • Review UsWe’d love to hear what you think.
  • Contact
    • Jamestown, NY Office
      • 519 Washington Street, P.O. Box 3026
        Jamestown, NY 14702-3026
      • 716-483-5525
      • robin@garynjohnsoninsurance.com
      • Office Hours: 9-4, M-F
      • Review Us
      • Refer Us
    • ContactVisit our Jamestown, NY, office.
  • Pay Bill
  • 716-483-5525
  • Request Quote
  • search
  • Insurance Solutions
    • –
      • Personal Insurance
        • Auto
        • Home
        • Secondary Home
        • See All
      • Insurance by Industry
        • Landlord and Rental Property
        • Property Manager
        • Retail Business
        • See All
    • –
      • Business Insurance
        • Business Auto
        • Commercial Property
        • General Liability
        • See All
    • Explore Interactive GraphicsClick it. Read it. Cover it.
  • About
    • About Our Agency
      • Meet the Owner
      • Read Our Reviews
      • Insurance Companies
      • We Are Independent
      • Renaissance Alliance
    • Review UsWe’d love to hear what you think.
  • Contact
    • Jamestown, NY Office
      • 519 Washington Street, P.O. Box 3026
        Jamestown, NY 14702-3026
      • 716-483-5525
      • robin@garynjohnsoninsurance.com
      • Office Hours: 9-4, M-F
      • Review Us
      • Refer Us
    • ContactVisit our Jamestown, NY, office.
  • Pay Bill
  • 716-483-5525
  • Request Quote
  • Visit Gary N. Johnson Insurance Agency on Facebook
  • Visit Gary N. Johnson Insurance Agency on Instagram

Home » About Our Agency » Insurance Companies

Insurance Companies

We represent a variety of insurance companies to better serve you.

Chautauqua Patrons Insurance

General
Visit Website
Claims
Report Claim
Billing
Bill Pay

CNA Surety

General
Visit Website
800-331-6053
Claims
Report Claim
877-672-6115
Billing
Bill Pay
800-331-6053

Condon Skelly

General
Visit Website
800-257-9496
Claims
Report Claim
800-257-9496
Billing
Bill Pay
800-257-9496

Foremost

General
Visit Website
800-527-3905
Claims
Report Claim
800-527-3907
Billing
Bill Pay
800-532-4221

Hagerty

General
Visit Website
877-922-9701
Claims
Report Claim
800-385-0274
Billing
Bill Pay
877-922-9701

JC Taylor

General
Visit Website
800-345-8290
Claims
800-272-6764
Billing
Bill Pay
800-345-8290

National General

General
Visit Website
833-684-0492
Claims
Report Claim
800-468-3466
Billing
Bill Pay
833-684-0492

Philadelphia Insurance Companies

General
Visit Website
877-438-7459
Claims
Report Claim
800-765-9749
Billing
Bill Pay
800-765-9749

Progressive

General
Visit Website
888-671-4405
Claims
Report Claim
800-776-4737
Billing
Bill Pay
888-671-4405

Safeco Insurance

General
Visit Website
800-332-3226
Claims
Report Claim
800-332-3226
Billing
Bill Pay
800-332-3226

Shelterpoint

General
Visit Website
800-365-4999
Claims
Report Claim
Billing
Bill Pay

Travelers

General
Visit Website
800-842-5075
Claims
Report Claim
800-252-4633
Billing
Bill Pay
800-842-5075

Prefer to speak with someone from Gary N. Johnson Insurance Agency?
Contact us directly.

Contact Us

Insurance Solutions

  • Personal Insurance
  • Business Insurance
  • Insurance by Industry
  • Explore Interactive Graphics

About Gary N. Johnson Insurance Agency

  • About Our Agency
  • Meet the Owner
  • Read Our Reviews
  • We Are Independent

Get Help

  • Pay Bill
  • Insurance Companies
  • Request Quote
  • Web Accessibility

Contact Us

519 Washington Street
P.O. Box 3026
Jamestown, NY 14702-3026

 716-483-5525
Email Us
716-664-0933 fax

Visit Our Jamestown, NY Office

Experience the Value of an Independent Agency

At Gary N. Johnson Insurance Agency, we represent several regional and national carriers and offer multiple lines of personal and commercial insurance to meet your needs. We offer personal and professional service to our customers and strive to stay competitive in today’s insurance industry.

We are licensed in NY, OH, PA, and VT.

© 2023 Gary N. Johnson Insurance Agency | Powered by Forge3 ActiveAgency | All rights reserved | Privacy Policy

View Power Panels
Hide Power Panels
Hide Power Panels
Hide Power Panels
We're ready to help meet your insurance needs.
We're ready to help meet your insurance needs.
Get a Quote Contact Us
Hello Producer
716-483-5525robin@garynjohnsoninsurance.comRead About %name%
Hello Producer